[ODDS and EVENS] Eddie Jones is Not a Good Fit for the Brave Blossoms

Has the Japan Rugby Football Union already made Eddie Jones an offer that's too good to refuse?

Is Jones the right person to lead the Brave Blossoms in the post-Jamie Joseph era?

Will JRFU's top decision makers wholeheartedly consider other coaching candidates besides Jones?

Would a second stint for Jones at the helm be a misguided attempt to turn the clock back to the 2015 Rugby World Cup?

Answers to these questions will materialize in the coming weeks, months and years.

What is clear, however, in my view, is that Jones' gravitas within the global rugby community has fallen. Furthermore, it may be too early to determine if Jones can regain his mojo. But recent results appear to indicate he is on the downside of his coaching career.

Consider: In December 2022, England Rugby fired Jones after the team lost its seventh consecutive match. Steve Borthwick, Jones' successor, then guided England to a third-place finish, a 26-23 decision over Argentina, at the 2023 Rugby World Cup. New leadership proved to be a critical component of England's success this year.

In January 2023, Jones took over as Australia's new rugby head coach. He signed a five-year contract through the end of the 2027 Rugby World Cup, which will be held in his native Australia.

That contract proved to be a meaningless piece of paper.

The End of an Era for Eddie Jones and the Wallabies

Jones, 63, officially resigned on Sunday, October 28, weeks after the Wallabies' disastrous performance at the RWC in France.

"I feel disappointment about the fact that what we wanted to do in terms of changing the system hasn't been able to happen in the short term," Jones was quoted as saying by The Associated Press. 

He added: "I have a major feeling of disappointment. But I don't feel any grievance towards anyone. I've really enjoyed coaching the players. The players have been fantastic. They just need a better environment to be training and playing in."

Two-time RWC champion Australia (2-2) failed to advance out of the pool stage for the first time ever at the recently completed quadrennial tournament.

What's more, before the Rugby World Cup kicked off, the Wallabies suffered five consecutive defeats. Widespread criticism of roster selections, including the decision to leave former Australia captain Michael Hooper off the squad, appeared in Australian media reports.

A quick review: Two long losing streaks with two different national teams with Jones at the helm, with both occurring in a critical stage during the run-up to the sport's biggest tournament.

There are times when an individual's leadership approach and/or skill set don't match the demands of calling the shots for a team or organization.

Based on the results, it appears that Jones was a bad fit for both England and Australia.

JRFU Reportedly Interviewed Jones Before the Rugby World Cup

And it's relevant to this discussion to ask the following: Was Jones genuinely 100% committed to leading the Wallabies until 2027?

Before the Rugby World Cup began in September in France, Jones participated in a Zoom interview session in late August with JRFU officials about the national team's head coaching position, according to published reports.

Jones denied the reports. He also told Australian Channel 9 TV, "I've got no job to go to, no job offer."

And the JRFU didn't offer a definitive denial nor confirmation of the reports (viewed as simply rumors to many).

An orginazation spokesperson told The Sydney Morning Herald: "[The] JRFU won't disclose any information about candidates [name of individual or progress] until we decide and announce the new head coach, so unfortunately there is no comment from us so far because it's not been decided."

But as the news spread like wildfire, it became a big distraction for the Wallabies.

And even after Australia's departure following the pool stage, Jones' insistence that he wasn't leaving the team was less than convincing.

"I'm staying, mate. I've always been committed to Australian rugby. I want to leave it in a better place, and that's still the job," he said, according to The Sydney Morning Herald in mid-October.

Insights on Jones' Last Two Coaching Stints

Speaking on the BBC Rugby Union Daily podcast, former England wing Ugo Monye insisted that Jones' star has fallen.

"In the last year, Eddie has lost the English rugby public and then the Australian rugby public in eight games," Monye told the podcast. That's a remarkable skill."

Monye added this scathing critique of Jones' short tenure with the Wallabies: "You can't come in and uproot a coaching staff, sack off some legends of the game, take a punt on some young kids, get booted from a World Cup and then say 'cheerio.' " 

According to an Australian Broadcasting Corporation report Jones is one of three candidates to "meet with a Japanese selection panel" in early November to fill the Brave Blossoms' coaching vacancy. The broadcaster added that JRFU President Masato Tsuchida, one of the panel members, wants Jones to be appointed.

Jones had success in leading Australia to a runner-up finish in the 2003 Rugby World Cup final in his first stint leading the Wallabies (2001-05) and helping Japan improve in leaps and bounds from 2012-15.

That said, for the Brave Blossoms, I believe, new leadership ― not a desire for a fantasied return to a former era ― is the best approach to plant the seeds for future success.

RELATED:

• Rugby World Cup: Pool Stage Review and Knockout Stage Predictions
• 2023 Rugby World Cup: Group Stage Preview

Author: Ed Odeven

Find Ed on JAPAN Forward's dedicated website, SportsLook. Follow his [Japan Sports Notebook] on Sundays, [Odds and Evens] during the week, and X (formerly Twitter) ＠ed_odeven.